I thought I’d take a few moments to attempt to put my many layers of feelings about this issue on paper.
When Beckham first moved to this league, I had very mixed feelings. I hate it when aging European-based players mention MLS as a way to get a last paycheck. This is old thinking, based on the old NASL of Pele and Beckenbauer. MLS is a lot smarter – built for long term financial stability. There are severe financial constraints on each team. But the powers that be recognized that big names can have a multiplier effect in terms of media exposure and revenues. So they created a rule that allowed each team the opportunity to sign one player outside the pay constraints. And LA took the opportunity to sign Beckham. They threw a ridiculous amount of money at him, and have more than gotten it back. Very good ROI. To that extent, it was an unbridled success. And no, I don’t think Beckham did it only for the money. He was genuinely interested in coming to LA, genuinely interested in contributing to the building of the league.
The problem comes with expectations. Beckham has long been the most famous footballer in the world, but he was never close to being the best. Top 50 in the world, at his peak, maybe, and that’s not bad. The irony, though, is that Beckham is so overrated that he’s actually underrated. He’s a damn fine football player. He’s on the downslope of his career, but just barely. He’s a fitness nut, and contrary to his public image, he’s no primadonna on the field – he’s always gone in hard for tackles, worked on defense, and gained the respect of his teammates. But when you’re getting paid more than 10 times the leagues official MAXIMUM salary, then the people want more. When you’re on a team where two players take up more than 60% of the salary cap, that’s a problem. It’s just not going to happen. So the haters will say that he’s overrated and washed up. The eurosnobs will say that his teammates can’t hang with him, don’t have the tactical sophistication to understand his passing, and they’ll point to his success at AC Milan as proof. There’s a shred of truth to this last one, but remember, AC Milan is an aging team in a league known for bunker defending, which means everybody has space and time to play. I would look good playing for AC Milan.
Beckham claims that he is motivated by playing on the English national team in one more world cup. I believe him 100%. In order to accomplish this, he believes that he needs to play more games than MLS offers, and to play games during MLS’ long winter break. He’s probably 100% right on both of these counts. He also believes that the English manager doesn’t think highly of MLS, and thinks he needs to be playing at a higher level. On this, Beckham is also 100% right, the English manager doesn’t rate MLS, but the English manager is wrong. Sure, MLS is not the Premier League, but it’s not a backwater either. Beckham knows it, too. That’s why he came. But he’s not come out strongly, saying “stop calling MLS a third-rate league.” He should have. That would have gone a long way.
Also, let’s not forget the fact that at the time Beckham signed with the Galaxy, he had about zero chance of playing in WC2010. He wasn’t getting off the bench at Madrid. It was the fact that he was getting games regularly in LA, and doing well, that brought him back into the national team radar. If not for MLS, Beckham wouldn’t have even had a WC dream, and this is something he never speaks about publicly. And that’s what pisses me off the most. It’s revisionist history.
The things that Donovan said about Beckham, virtually nobody is denying them. Donovan showed a little lack of maturity and lack of sophistication by saying them publicly before saying them privately, but these things happen. In some ways, that’s why we love Donovan. Those are his warts. Beckham showed a lot of class, by saying little upon his return. He’s a classy guy. And it’s not just image. But he’s also a wounded beast, and that’s what came out when he lashed out at the fans yesterday. Athletes should never engage with fans – no matter what. Remember basketball’s Palace Brawl?
So where do we go from here? I don’t see it getting any better. It’s going to be an exceedingly uncomfortable season. At the end of which, LA should play hardball with Beckham, force him to buy out his contract, so he can play in Europe and in the World Cup. Beckham really could have been the guy to help build soccer in this country. But he’s blown his credibility, and MLS should go ahead and burn that bridge.
I have opinions.
July 20th, 2009 | Leave a comment